“Sanity” by Marcel Eschauzier: a critical examination of Western thought

In today’s polarized world, understanding the roots of societal discord is more crucial than ever. Marcel Eschauzier’s Sanity: Humanism Is a Dualism offers a penetrating, religion-agnostic analysis of Western thought, challenging readers to reconsider fundamental assumptions about rationality, morality, and social progress. This comprehensive review explores the book’s key themes, the potential benefits for readers, and its target audience.

Understanding structural errors in secular dualistic thought

The book Sanity by Marcel Eschauzier presents an examination of the structural errors in secular dualistic Western thought. It argues that these errors contribute to a pervasive irrationality that threatens the very fabric of Western civilization. The author proposes a diagnosis of this condition and offers a cure through rational nondualism, which contrasts sharply with the prevailing moral absolutism. Rational nondualism stands as a philosophical bridge, harmonizing with both religious faith and secular thought while committing to neither.

The book’s scope is ambitious, touching on historical parallels, existential insights, and critiques of ideological extremes. Eschauzier draws connections between past events and current societal trends, questioning the efficacy of Western interventions in global conflicts and encouraging readers to consider the long-term consequences of our collective actions.

The title of the book is a nod to Jean-Paul Sartre’s Existentialism Is a Humanism (1946). Written in the aftermath of World War II, Sartre’s exploration of existentialism was profoundly shaped by the war’s horrors and reflects a thought pattern that continues to influence Western thought today. In Sanity, Eschauzier critiques this dualistic framework, arguing that it misinterprets humanistic values—rooted in two millennia of Christianity—as objective moral standards. This flawed perspective, he contends, contributes to the irrationality plaguing contemporary society.

Diagnosis of the Western mental condition

Eschauzier identifies secular dualism as a fundamental flaw in contemporary Western thinking. This dualism involves excessive faith in human cognitive abilities, particularly in understanding consciousness itself. Accordingly, it overestimates science’s reach and leads to a rigid separation between opposing concepts—such as good and evil, success and failure, or freedom and oppression—leading to moral absolutism. Thus, secular dualism breeds exceptionalism, division, and conflict.

Why can’t humankind conceive an explanation for consciousness? The author argues that since it is only immediately and privately known, any understanding of consciousness must itself arise through conscious experience. This entails that consciousness contains within itself both the mystery and its solution.

The book posits that this dualistic mindset has contributed to a societal atmosphere where blame is easily assigned to external entities, such as political opponents or cultural movements, rather than engaging in self-reflection and collective responsibility. The author argues that this mindset has led to a crisis in free speech, where dissenting opinions are increasingly silenced under the guise of protecting societal norms.

The cure: rational nondualism

Eschauzier advocates for rational nondualism as a remedy for the irrationality stemming from secular dualism. This philosophical approach encourages individuals to recognize the illusion of separation between object and subject, thereby delineating the immense breadth and limitations of rational thought. By understanding and embracing these human boundaries, individuals can move beyond polar thinking and better appreciate the role of intuition and rational beliefs in dealing with complex existential issues.

The author emphasizes that rational nondualism does not reject reason or science; rather, it enhances them by integrating reasonable insights from Eastern metaphysics. This integration allows for more cultural sensitivity.

Key themes in “Sanity”

1. Secular dualism: Eschauzier identifies this as a primary flaw in Western thinking, leading to oversimplified binary perspectives on complex issues, and a “tyranny of good intentions.”
2. Rational nondualism: Proposed as an alternative framework, integrating “Eastern” metaphysics with “Western” logic for a worldview that is compatible with religion and science.
3. Crisis in free speech: The book examines how thinking in opposites contributes to the suppression of diverse viewpoints.
4. Historical context: Drawing parallels between past events and current societal trends to illuminate recurring patterns.
5. Critique of ideological extremes: A balanced examination of how extreme positions on both ends of the spectrum hinder progress.

Why “Sanity” matters in today’s world

In an era of increasing polarization and social media echo chambers, Eschauzier’s work provides a timely reminder of the importance of common sense: intuition based on rational beliefs. By examining the structural flaws in Western thought, Sanity offers readers tools to deal with the complexities of modern discourse more effectively.

The book’s exploration of rational nondualism presents an intriguing alternative to the dualistic thinking that often dominates public debate. This approach could be particularly valuable for those seeking to bridge ideological divides and have more constructive dialogue on pressing social issues.

Key benefits for readers

1. Expanded worldview: Gain insights into alternative ways of thinking about societal issues.
2. Enhanced critical thinking: Develop skills to analyze complex problems from multiple perspectives.
3. Historical context: Understand current events with historical patterns and philosophical trends.
4. Intellectual growth: Challenge your assumptions and deepen your understanding of Eastern metaphysics.
5. Improved dialogue skills: Learn to engage more effectively in discussions about controversial topics.

Who might benefit from reading “Sanity”?

• Critical thinkers: Those who enjoy challenging their own beliefs and engaging with complex philosophical ideas.
• Socially conscious individuals: Readers concerned about societal issues like free speech, cultural division, and political polarization.
• Philosophy enthusiasts: Anyone interested in a meeting of Eastern and Western philosophical traditions.
• Academics and students: Particularly those in fields like philosophy, sociology, political science, and cultural studies.
• Policymakers and influencers: Those looking for fresh perspectives on addressing societal challenges.

Who may want to skip it?

• Casual readers: The book’s depth and complexity may be challenging for those seeking lighter material.
• Staunch ideologues: Individuals firmly entrenched in dogmatic political positions might find the critiques uncomfortable.

Conclusion: a challenging but rewarding read

Sanity is not a book for the faint of heart. It demands engagement, reflection, and a willingness to question deeply held beliefs. However, for those ready to embark on an intellectual journey, Eschauzier’s work offers profound insights into the nature of rationality, morality, and social progress.

Whether you’re a student of philosophy, a concerned citizen, or simply someone looking to understand the world better, Sanity provides a thought-provoking exploration of the challenges facing Western civilization. By confronting these issues head-on, Eschauzier invites readers to participate in the crucial task of reimagining our collective future.

In a world often characterized by superficial analysis and knee-jerk reactions, Sanity stands out as a beacon of thoughtful yet resolute examination. The author is a trained engineer, which makes his discourse less ambiguous and more hands-on than what academic philosophers typically have to offer. For those willing to engage with its challenging ideas, this book offers not just a critique of current thinking, but a potential pathway towards a more rational, peaceful, and cooperative world.

From the back cover

“What about objectivity when the separation between the observer and the observed is an illusion? This paradox holds the key to common sense—and its scarcity in today’s public discourse. In Sanity, you will:

• Discover how nonduality enhances rather than threatens scientific inquiry
• Learn why intuition and logic are natural allies, not opponents
• Uncover why modern humanism creates the very problems it aims to solve
• See how this blind spot shapes world leaders’ decisions today

Why are we edging toward World War III? Our planet has sufficient sustainable resources, so the culprit seems to be cultural and philosophical. The post-religious West dogmatically wields its moral values, preaching rationality while failing to recognize the limits of our dualistic thinking.

Sanity delves into the nature of consciousness to show why science alone cannot answer existential questions. How should we address them instead? Rather than absolving ourselves with good intentions, we need more common sense, guided by a philosophy that bridges Western rationality and Eastern nondualism.

Rational nondualism, as championed by Marcel Eschauzier, offers a groundbreaking synthesis of these two philosophical traditions. With zeal and dexterity, Eschauzier explains why nonduality is not a choice but a fact—and why understanding this has never been more urgent.”

What readers say

“What a great analysis of the current state of affairs, and entertaining as well! The author expresses things I had only intuited but couldn’t put in words. I absolutely recommend it to everyone who wants to understand the heart of the problem of our society, and the change in understanding of reality we need to fix it. A powerful book for sure!”—Amazon customer

 “I hope many people will read it.”—Amazon customer

Best Deal

Amazon Kindle | Paperback | Hardcover | All retailers

Discover more articles about Marcel Eschauzier’s books here.